The following article was written by Dave Dinkle who is a real estate investor in Broward County. I thought he explained the process pretty well of what you need to do if you want to fight your property tax assessment. This is specifically for South Florida, but the process is similar in other parts of the US, too. Check with your county about the specifics for where you live.
“The Tax Appeal Process
You think your property assessment is too high and decide to file a petition to appeal. What’s the next step?
First, get your petition filed on time. The filing deadline is September 18th in Broward County and September 14th in Palm Beach, Dade County has not yet announced their date. Whether you try to do the appeal yourself or you engage a professional to do it for you, this is the first important step. Secondly, 80% of success is showing up! Make sure you complete the form in full and all information is correct. VERY IMPORTANT – if you file your own petition and later realize that you are in over your head, you can still engage someone to take over as long as you have filed your petition on time.
What does a professional do for you? After filing the petition in person at the VAB office, they typically will go for a meeting at the office of the Property Appraiser to see if they can negotiate a reduction in the assessment. WARNING – This is not for the novice or even for fee appraisers who do not understand the complicated appraisal process used by the county.
To get a tax assessment for your property, the county appraiser will go through the process of the determination of the value. First, he or she will choose a land sale (hopefully in your neighborhood, but not always) on which to base your land value. Land evaluations can be tricky especially since some areas have very few land sales. Values can change from neighborhood to neighborhood or even from block to block. If the land parcel they choose has more value than your land, it can adversely affect your assessment.
Let’s look at a typical example:
Your property is in Mudville, but there have been no land sales there in the base year. The county appraiser finds a land sale in the town of Happyville, just to the north, which he uses as a basis for the land valuation in your assessment. However, Happyville is a bit more upscale than Mudville, even though it is geographically close by.
The price per square foot of land in Happyville is greater than the price of land in Mudville, but the average citizen does not know the difference, and does not realize how much his assessment can be affected by an inappropriate land valuation. Let’s say that a 7,000 SF parcel sold for $140,000 in Happyville. That’s $20.00 per SF. A similar sized parcel in Mudville may sell for $70,000 or $10.00 per SF. You have an 8,500 SF lot which by Mudville standards should be valued at $85,000, but because there was no land sales in Mudville, the county appraiser uses the closest land sale which happens to be in Happyville. Your land then gets valued at $20.00 per SF or $170,000. Your taxes are already about $1,700 too high before he even starts on the house!
Then you say, “Mr. Appraiser, I don’t think you should be using a land sale from Happyville.” And he says, “OK, what land sale do you suggest we use?”… This is where the pros make you money while the average homeowner goes home all bent out of shape.
An actual land example – In Broward County, the tax assessor’s office uses an adjusted front footage when dealing with land. If the land depth is not 100′, they adjust. For example, in one area, the standard lot is 50′ x 135′ or 6,750 SF, but what is shown on the tax record is 55.90 Front Feet. (FF). If a lot is 50′ x 100″ or 5,000 SF, you will see 50.00 FF. By using the FF, you would think that the size of the second lot is 89.4% of the size of the first lot (50/55.9 = .894), while in reality it is 74% of the size of the first lot (5000/6750 = 74.1%). What’s more, these adjusted FF are not uniform across the county. Remember, land is tricky!
Another and even a better example – one of the more confusing adjustments used in establishing assessments in houses is the “high ceiling” adjustment, which is either 1.1 or 1.3 times the area with a higher ceiling. In a two-story house, if a 500 SF area has a volume ceiling, the SF used in calculating the assessment is 1.3 x 500 = 650 SF. If a 1-story house has high ceilings in the living areas, but not the bedrooms, the SF of just the living areas should be multiplied by 1.1. However, BCPA has been known to multiply the area of the entire house by the 1.1 factor. They claim that if they use this process uniformly across an entire neighborhood that it is fair. However, if you don’t know what is used across the neighborhood, you can’t make an adjustment that you may be entitled to! Remember, appeals are tricky!
An assessment can be challenged by using either the tax assessor’s method of adjusted SF or the traditional appraiser’s method of “under air” living area. Whatever method is selected, it should be applied uniformly across the subject property and all the comparables. Do not use adjusted SF on the comps and living area on the subject property only. You must always compare apples to apples. Make sure your adjustments are plausible and you have data to back them up.”
Here is a trick I learned today.



